low appraisals

Getting More Money Out of a Low Appraisal in West Sacramento

seller's bottom lineWhen the seller of a home in West Sacramento contacted this Sacramento REALTOR, he already had a different listing agent in mind, an agent who would charge less than the commission that agents like me charge and he was just about ready to hire this other real estate agent. See, this is where some sellers typically go off track. They tend to focus solely on the commission and not on results. They don’t know any better. They think about saving 1% of the sales price, for example, and don’t look ahead to how much they are probably losing during escrow because they’ve hired an inexperienced agent who can only sell herself by discounting her fee.

Getting into escrow, into contract, is just the beginning. There are home inspections, disclosures, repair requests, and more negotiations that happen during escrow, including dealing with shaky buyers who can’t get a mortgage.

Fortunately, this seller listened to his friend who had referred him to me, and he listened to my advice. He decided it was worth it to hire the best Sacramento REALTOR he could find, a top producer. I explained what I would do and how I would do it, and then he asked me how much his home was worth. The comparable sales reflected, let’s say for practical illustration purposes, a price of $650,000, tops, and that was stretching it. Because any agent worth her salt realizes an appraiser will use comparable sales within a 1/2 mile radius of the property and within the past 3 months. Appraisers are supposed to compare condition, location, age, upgrades, size, etc, and pick similar homes. But every appraiser is different, just like every real estate agent is different.

I didn’t ask the seller how much he wanted because in most cases how much a seller wants is immaterial; instead he shared in no uncertain terms that he expected to get, let’s say, $675,000. Would I take such a listing? Could I get him $675,000? I licked my finger and held it in the air to confirm which way the wind blows. Yup. I could. I shot terrific digital photos that showcased the home in all of its glory, and it was a stunning home. I tell stories with my pictures. If the photos speak to me, they will speak to the buyers.

This home in West Sacramento sold at, let’s say, $675,000. Then, the appraiser, an old-school dude who has his own way of doing things, submitted his final estimate of value. $650,000. Market demand is not a value. We got a low appraisal in West Sacramento. We were $25,000 short. This is NOT what the seller desired. I asked the buyer’s agent to discuss the situation with the buyer and put forth in an addendum the buyer’s best cash contribution.

The buyer offered an additional, let’s say, $12,000 in cash to bridge part of the gap. This was a good workable situation because now we knew the buyer has access to additional funds. We were in negotiation, not at the final step. We countered the buyer’s contribution, and the buyer’s countered back. We countered again. The seller asked if I could find additional money anywhere else. Ha, ha, ha. No, there are no other pockets. Oh, wait, we didn’t talk to the lender.

For a small adjustment to the interest rate, the lender was able to find more money that suddenly became available to pay much of the seller’s closing costs. By transferring a large chunk of the seller’s closings to the buyer’s side of the settlement statement and allowing the lender to pay it, the sales price did not need to increase by the full $25,000 to net the seller his desired amount.

Was this worth hiring an experienced agent who charges more than a discount agent? You betcha. I could not ask for a more ecstatic West Sacramento home seller. At closing the seller called me a “Real Estate Rockstar.” I go that extra mile for my clients. Would you like to be my client? Let’s talk. Call Elizabeth Weintraub, Broker #00697006, at 916.233.6759.

An Overpriced Listing Versus an Overpriced Buyer in Sacramento

overpriced listing

An overpriced listing is not inherently bad unless more negatives are in the picture.

If I’m gonna take an overpriced listing, I have to really like the seller. Because I know that I will be in a long-term relationship with that seller as we work toward price reductions, pulling the home off the market, putting it back as a new listing, and fielding unending agent comments about the crazy price after showings that go nowhere. Yet, little messes up that relationship more quickly than when a seller demands I discount my fee for no good reason.

Sellers like this are basically saying, hey, we want you to work like a dog trying to get a price for our home that is impossible to obtain, and we don’t want to pay your going rate. That’s three strikes, the third being brain damage. Rottsaruck there, buddy. You deserve to work with a discount agent, yes, sirree. Go hire a discount agent who will shoot pictures with a cellphone and throw you under the bus after the buyer’s home inspection. See how happy that makes you.

But I don’t tell them this because they wouldn’t believe me anyway. They don’t work in Sacramento real estate and they don’t really know our market. They don’t realize they will lose far more money than they hope to save. These guys don’t view their home as an overpriced listing because they don’t understand how appraisals work. It has never occurred to them that the home needs to appraise at the sales price.

A few weeks ago, I had an agent call me to say she had shown her buyer one of my listings and “unknown” to her, this guy snuck back over to the house, knocked on the door and offered the seller a huge sum of money. Well, we all suspect that the agent told him to do it, but can’t report the agent due to lack of concrete evidence. I called the seller while the buyer was there and had him put me on speaker phone.

Hey, Tony, I said, (not his real name). I hear you offered the seller $500,000 for this house, (not the real price).

Yes, I did, and the seller accepted it.

I have bad news for you, Tony, the seller doesn’t want $500K; the seller would really like a million dollars!

Much laughter. I could hear the seller agreeing with me.

Hey, Tony, I continued, how much money do you have?

I’ve got some money, he said.

Good, Tony, have you got an extra fifty-thousand dollars? Because if this home doesn’t appraise at the value you offered, you’re gonna have to give that $50,000 to the seller. Do you wanna do that, Tony?

Oh! I didn’t know it works that way, he replied.

In this case, I did not have an overpriced listing. I had a listing that was priced right. We were dealing with an overpriced buyer.

Is Your Home for Sale at Too Low of a Price?

Sacramento-List-PricesSellers are often amazed when they immediately receive an offer after going on the market in Sacramento. Part of that amazement comes from not fully realizing the reach and breadth of our MLS and Internet marketing. Everything is instant nowadays. People have no patience for anything. They want it now, and two hours ago would be even better. However, when you consider the fact that we are now in a seller’s market — which means buyers are camped out in your back yard, lurking around the corner, ready to jump out at you when you take out the morning trash and shout SURPRISE, here is a full price offer plus a little bit more — it is not really amazing at all to get a fast response on your home for sale.

But there will always be sellers who genuinely believe that if they receive an offer as soon as the home goes on the market, they must have priced it too low. I don’t know where they get that idea. They could have priced that home in Sacramento at such a high price point where it won’t ever appraise until Honey Boo Boo grows up to become president, god forbid, but buyers still might make an offer on that home for sale. The price of a home can make or break a transaction, and homes that won’t appraise are unlikely to close escrow.

But then a seller will have the right to march around and tell all her friends that she got a whopping offer for her house but the appraisal just messed up everything. That appraisers don’t know what they are doing. And some of them don’t. That’s part of the problem, too.

I tell my sellers to respond to offers within 2 to 3 days. Buyers don’t like to wait more than a day or two at the most. It’s possible that subsequent offers might be higher but they might not. The best offer is not always the highest. Sometimes the best offer is your first offer and sometimes it’s not. There is no hard and fast rule for offers on a home for sale.

But just because you received an offer right away doesn’t mean you’ve priced it too low. It means you have priced it just right.

Subscribe to Elizabeth Weintraub\'s Blog via email